Which tube is it for Euston Station?

Posted on March 11, 2010

 

Microsoft this week launched a series of adverts in the UK to promote its Bing search engine, with the slogan ‘Bing and decide’. The adverts claim that we, as a people, are suffering from information overload by using other, more successful, search engines and we can’t find a simple answer to a simple question.

One of the adverts showed a woman in a train station asking a man which tube she should take for Euston Station, where the man promptly offered every piece of information relating to Euston Station… save for what she asked.

The idea of the advert is that if you use Bing, instead of say, Google, you’ll cut out all of the useless information and get straight to the nub of the matter.

But will you?

We asked Google and Bing exactly that question, which tube is it for Euston Station?

You’d think, seeing as Microsoft are making such a fuss over how their search engine gives answers, rather than ‘information overload’, they’d have made sure that the answer to this question was succinct and accurate… you’d think.

Here is what Google offered:

Google

Wikipedia is first and second, goes without saying. The third result is AllinLondon.co.uk – which offers loads of info, but not necessarily the answer to our question. Fourth up is metazone.co.uk – which has the answer in great detail, showing how we can plan our route. Nice one Google, third site, fourth result down had the answer.

Here is what Bing offered, despite being the question asked in a multi-million pound advertising campaign:

Bing

First two again are Wikipedia results, same as Google. Next is AllinLondon.co.uk again, same as Google. Not much difference so far, the same information overload. The fourth result is another page for AllinLondon.co.uk, showing restaurants near Euston – not really what we asked, but nice to know.

The fifth result is alwaystouchout.com, which shows us development projects in London. We’re getting a bit off track now. We’re then offered davros.org, which shows us a history of London Underground lines… after this we gave up.

So, which search engine answered the question in a succinct manner? Google. Which search engine offered reams of information that failed to answer our question? Bing.

Nice one Microsoft, may as well have just shot your own foot while you were at it. Here’s the advert anyway, in case you think we’ve made this up.

Darren Jamieson

Technical Director at Engage Web
Darren is Technical Director at Engage Web, as well as being a co-founder of the company. He takes a hands-on approach to SEO and web design, helped by more than 15 years’ experience in these fields.

Like us on Facebook to see more posts like this

You might also be interested in:

8 Comments »

  1. Mmm. Seeing as the woman in question was stood in Canary Wharf Tube station she’d obviously walked past the Tube map at the top of the escalators and was succesfully ignoring the ones in the station itself. If she she hasn’t got the intelligence to look at the map Bing ain’t gonna help her. A crap ad in just about every respect.

    Comment by Nick — March 11, 2010 @ 9:38 pm

  2. […] many Microsoft products, the marketing noise is not matched by the quality of the end product, as this post by Stuckon poignantly points […]

    Pingback by Bing’s marketing push | redsauce.com — March 12, 2010 @ 11:57 am

  3. Bing is completely irrelevent in this advert. This woman is obviously someone who lives in London or the surrounding area, considering the child whose hand she’s holding is in a school uniform. And if he’s in a school uniform, the reason they’re at Canary Wharf most likely could’ve been for him. She should know where she’s going if she’s looking after a child.
    Moreover, there’s only one tube line going through that station, and considering she’s east of the city center where Euston is, common sense should’ve told her she’d have to get the one westbound line there. After that there’s always tube maps on the trains.
    For a ‘multi-million pound’ campaign surely they could’ve managed to do some research.

    Comment by Charlotte — August 21, 2010 @ 4:23 pm

  4. Perhaps we should have a word with the Advertisng Standards Authourity?

    On the other hand if all the idiots who don’t know how to use quotes and “-” (for exclude) got to Bing then perhaps Google will loose market share and end up like AltaVista. If only Compaq hadn’t cast it adrift all those years ago.

    Comment by Dave — August 22, 2010 @ 10:33 am

  5. […] wrote a post for Engage Web a few years ago about Bing’s TV advert left a lot to be desired when it came to their search […]

    Pingback by Bing v Google | Mr Daz — November 1, 2013 @ 12:18 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URL

Have your say!

Call Now Button

We have worked with:

minute-man-press-image
TEL: 0345 621 4321